Flexi Jewelry

Brand New Arrivals
Dive into Summer with our

Larimar Collection

Capture the essence of the Caribbean
*ONE-OF-A-KIND DIAMONDS*

Rose Cut Diamonds

ANTIQUE CUT WITH SOFT BRILLIANCE AND A MYSTERIOUS LOOK

Visiting the Caribbean Soon?

One Iconic Blue Diamond Ring

in three stunning colors

ROSE GOLD | WHITE GOLD | YELLOW GOLD

Top Rated Jewelry Store in the Caribbean

Spanning the five breathtaking Caribbean islands of Aruba, Grand Cayman, Nassau, St. Maarten, and St. Thomas; each Kay’s Fine Jewelry boutique is run by a member of the original founding family.

NEW ARRIVALS

Diamond Jewelry

Shop Now
Featured

KFJ Exclusives

Shop Now

Featured Collections

Diamonds

Whether a new engagement or a silver anniversary, they are the truest expressions of enduring love.

Shop Diamonds

Gemstones

Like those who wear them, each stone possesses its own precious and colorful personality.

Shop Gemstones

Rings

Explore a collection of diamond and gemstone rings for every occasion and individual sense of style.

Shop Rings

Necklaces

Discover fashion statements boasting rare stone and precious metals in all lengths, weights and styles.

Shop Necklaces

Bracelets & Bangles

Whatever you are looking for simple or sensational, you will find it among our collection of “wrist candy”.

Shop Bracelets & Bangles

Earrings

From classic diamond designs to cascading works of art, our collection shines with possibilities.

Shop Earrings
Limited time

Ocean Collection

Award winning collection with Blue & White Diamonds
Discover Forever

Bridal Diamond Rings

Begin your forever with our stunning collection of handcrafted bridal rings. From timeless classics to modern designs, find the perfect symbol of your love story.
Shop Now
Crafted Just for You

Bespoke Jewelry

Bring your dream piece to life with our bespoke design service. Collaborate with our experts to create one-of-a-kind jewelry tailored to your vision.
Explore Now

A Family Legacy

At Kay’s Fine Jewelry, our business was born, built and continues to thrive because of one simple but unwavering philosophy. Customers are extended family.

Customer reviews